Lessons on Leadership - Organizational Culture, Penn State, and Avoidance

It will be many years before the implications of the child sexual abuse perpetrated by Jerry Sandusky will be fully understood. As details continue to emerge in the present we find a horrifying pattern of abuse over many years and an organizational culture that enabled individuals at multiple levels of leadership to look the other way. The echoes of disbelief from similar scandals in the church ring in our ears. We have learned how deluded and deceptive pedophiles can be in securing relationships of trust to exploit children, rationalizing abhorrent behavior as something other than what it is – criminal assault.

Added to our immense grief for the physical and psychological harm done to innocent lives, is the realization that when leaders are made aware of a possible act of abuse, the instinct is to duck and cover. Is this the result of an individual character flaw? Is there some lack of professional training or development? Did they not understand the expectations and responsibilities they carry in positions of authority?

The report released Thursday from the Special Investigative Counsel, Louis J. Freeh, former director of the FBI, details the many failures of leadership involved at Penn State. One reference in the executive summary, however, makes a much broader sweeping statement about the cultural context of the university and the community:

“A culture of reverence for the football program that is ingrained at all levels of the campus community.”

It seems this statement could be adapted to many settings in which the decision to act is mitigated by a fear of bad publicity. The generic version would read, “A culture of reverence for the [fill in the blank] that is ingrained at all levels of the [organization].” Suddenly the pain of the Penn State community feels closer as we all know circumstances in which our regard for individuals or institutions can cause us to compromise on standards that cross moral, legal or ethical boundaries.

As I followed the news coverage of the events surrounding the emergence of the scandal through the Sandusky trial, I was struck by two events that appeared out-of-place. First, when the Penn State board of trustees made the decision to terminate Coach Joe Paterno (along with President Graham Spanier), the crowds protesting the end of Paterno’s career at Penn State seemed odd. The investigation was ongoing. The facts had not surfaced publicly. Yet the exuberant devotion to a sports idol and elevation of the football program to cult status revealed a distorted culture. Children had been sexually abused. We had many more questions than answers. Yet the crowds celebrated the hero-status of someone who knew about it and didn’t stop it. The situation did not call for a celebration; it called for reflection.

Second, the conclusion of the trial delivered a stack of guilty verdicts for Jerry Sandusky. Here again, crowds gathered as if it was a pep rally following the game. The fans cheered as the lawyers emerged from the courthouse to offer “post-game” remarks much like the coach and the MVP of the championship team. Media interviews followed on strategy and tactics. The coach for the losing team signaled he would be back with an appeal. One of the commentators on the news broadcast I was watching was stunned by what he saw. As a trial lawyer himself, he had seen many post trial settings, but nothing like this. The situation did not call for celebration; it called for reflection.

It’s inexcusable, but understandable that a distorted cultural context can give pause to leaders charged to act in ways that may be misunderstood or unpopular. We have much to learn from this tragedy. We have to find ways of developing healthy organizational cultures that will not bend to fears of bad publicity, but remain steadfast in ensuring well-being, providing justice and acting with integrity.

Mark Putnam is president of Central College in Pella, Iowa. He authors a blog, Mark: my words, at http://blogs.central.edu/president/ and can be reached at president@central.edu.

 

via hard-ball-innovation.posterous.com